Guest Stars Emily Marie Palmer as Sister Isabella Kate Forbes as Mrs. Olivia Fairfax Bill Heck as Philip Starks Christopher Cassarino as The Man / Booth Lauren Lee Denham as Lily Gretchen Koerner as Miss Evans Kevin Patrick Murphy as Soldier Finnigan Donny Boaz as Ezekial Davis Daniel Romer as Cyrus Davis Thomas Blake, Jr. as Soldier #2 Justin Geer as Wounded Soldier Scott Thomas as Soldier #1 Kate Leek as Prostitute Zackery Phillip Roundy as Hiram Davis Mathias Alvarez as Mounted Union Soldier David Pittu as Inspector Mussey Anthony Reynolds as Lead Soldier