Guest Stars Matt Barr as Christopher "Sully" Sullivan Jim Beaver as Sheriff Charlie Mills C.J. Thomason as Jimmy Mance Dean Chekvala as J.D. Dunn Richard Burgi as Thomas Wellington Victor Webster as Hunter Jennings Co Starring Brandon Jay McLaren as Danny Brooks Gina Holden as Shea Allen Cassandra Sawtell as Madison Allen Claudette Mink as Katherine Wellington Amber Borycki as Beth Barrington Ali Liebert as Nikki Bolton Chris Gauthier as Malcolm Ross Beverley Elliott as Maggie Krell Ben Cotton as Shane Pierce David Lewis as Richard Allen Sean Rogerson as Joel Booth Nicholas Carella as Deputy Lillis Anna Mae Routledge as Kelly Seaver Sarah Smyth as Lucy Daramour Terence Kelly as Reverend Fain Robert Clarke as Bart Gables