Guest Stars Dana Daurey as Heather Tupperman Nicki Aycox as Lily Gallagher Michael Reilly Burke as Brady Pullman Cristine Rose as Cynthia Blake David Lee Smith as Paul Rutigliata Laura Harrington as Gina Vinton Tim Ransom as Dan Vinton Brad Grunberg as Flowers Delivery Leader Paul O'Brien as Mr. Tweedy Co Starring Toni DeRose as Patrice Adrian Neil as Waiter