Guest Stars Rebecca Balding as Elise Rothman Eric Dane as Jason Dean Jenny McCarthy as Mitzy Stillman Jennifer Sky as Mabel Stillman Melody Perkins as Margo Stillman Co Starring Niki Botelho as Elf Woman Michael Patrick McGill as Ray Glenn Taranto as Foreman Gwen Van Dam as Wife Jernard Burks as Security Guard Joanna Sanchez as Lupita Robert Alan Beuth as Salesman Todd Tucker as Gremlins Bill Smillie as Husband Kip Martin as Jack