Guest Stars Kerr Smith as Kyle Brody Jenya Lano as Inspector Sheridan Nick Lachey as Leslie St. Claire John Todd as Elder Shelby Fenner as Carly Harve Presnell as Captain Black Jack Cutting Sam Rubin as Movie Critic Michael E. Rodgers as First Mate Reznor James Patric Moran as Young Captain Black Jack Cutting Co Starring Todd Tucker as Creature Head Demon Bre Blair as Brenda Castillo Gloria LeRoy as Old Brenda Dona Hardy as Old Paige