Guest Stars Michael Weston as Adam Hornstock Keegan Connor Tracy as Priscilla Osterman Donnelly Rhodes as Judge Horace Leland Jolie Jenkins as Sandra Panitch Scott Mosenson as Phelps Co Starring Liam James as Young Shawn Sage Brocklebank as Buzz McNab Michael Eklund as Ruben Leonard Jan Bos as D.A. Norman Misura as Storage Attendant Osmond Bramble as Bailiff Mark Brandon as Jackson Hale Tom Tasse as Defense Lawyer Joel Garner as Control Room Tech Madison Graie as Juror #5 Michael Gordin Shore as Reporter #1 Credit Only Kirsten Nelson as Karen Vick