Guest Stars Ray Wise as Father Peter Westley Sherilyn Fenn as Maudette Hornsby Robyn Lively as Michelle Barker Lenny Von Dohlen as Sheriff Andrew Jackson Sheryl Lee as Dr. Donna Gooden Ryan McDonald as Jack Smith Dana Ashbrook as Robert "Bob" Barker Catherine E. Coulson as Wood Woman Co Starring Olivia Steele-Falconer as 12 Year-Old Girl John DeSantis as Seven Foot Tall Man Scott Lyster as Randy Jackson Peter MacRae as Wood Woman's Child Claire Smithies as Waitress / Flo Sheldon Yamkovy as Deputy Frost Kiara Le Blanc as Paula Merral