Guest Stars Jason O'Mara as Mill Creek Killer Maury Sterling as Jim Meyers Christopher B. Duncan as Agent James Sheridan David Barry Gray as Tom Carroll Co Starring Cory Tyler as Security Guard Trevor Olsen as Male Reporter Deborah Van Valkenburgh as Betty Inger Tudor as Female Reporter Karina Bennett as Female Reporter #2 Robert C. Koch as ND Agent Kate Rene Gleason as Female FBI Agent Jeff Grays as Sheriff's Deputy Victoria Garcia-Kelleher as Ellen Carroll Bethany Geaber as Hysterical Woman Scott Michael Morgan as Hollow Man Landall Goolsby as Male Reporter #2 Chip Hormess as Jason Mitchell Natalie Salins as Cara Becker Jonathan Kehoe as Angry Man Rochelle Greenwood as Marci Mitchell