Guest Stars Graham Clarke as Reporter Reece Rios as Unsub Stefanie McCall as Reporter #2 Tyler Jacob Moore as Brad Matthew Rocheleau as Scott Weldon Jonathan Goldstein as Detective John Fordham Ned Schmidtke as Austin Chapman Justin Sintic as Texting Detective Deborah Puette as Louise Hightower Ian Vogt as David Caston Karen Forest as Norma Renmar Katherine Conway as Dorris Archer Kathryn Michelle as Mary Ann Nate Donaldson as Faux Unsub Peggy McClellan as Allison Kittredge Sarah Lieving as Lucy Masters