Guest Stars Rex Linn as Detective Frank Tripp Eva LaRue as Natalia Boa Vista Boti Bliss as DNA Analyst Maxine Valera Brendan Fehr as Audio/Visual Tech Dan Cooper Joel West as Officer Aaron Jessop Damian Young as Walter Resden Alexandra Lydon as Jennifer Wilson Jose Yenque as Manuel Martinez Steve Ryan as Morris Yates Vince Grant as John Massry Co Starring Shelli Bergh as Paula Muro Haley Ramm as Young Jennifer Wilson Kerri Walsh Jennings as Herself Mike Faiola as Billy Kyle Kaplan as Foster Kid #1 Josh Jacobson as Young John Massry Candace Kroslak as Nicole Naja Hill as Kellie Misty May-Treanor as Herself Todd Nakamura as Officer #1 Atom Gorelick as Young Walter Resden