Guest Stars Brandon J. Dirden as FBI Agent Dennis Aderholt Frank Langella as Gabriel Kelly AuCoin as Pastor Tim Peter Mark Kendall as Hans Cotter Smith as Deputy Attorney General Rahul Khanna as Yousaf Rana Gillian Alexy as Annelise Scott William Winters as Lawrence Jordan Baker as Charlotte Co Starring Vera Cherny as Tatiana Evgenyevna Vyazemtseva Aaron Roman Weiner as Agent Brooks Todd Faulkner as Agent Loeb Abraham Makany as Mujahideen Commander Jeté Laurence as Young Paige Debargo Sanyal as Nicholas Kate Greer as Drunkard