Guest Stars Monica Potter as Lori Colson Rhona Mitra as Tara Wilson Betty White as Catherine Piper Takayo Fischer as Court Clerk Leslie Jordan as Bernard Ferrion John Thaddeus as Detective John Stephenson Kurt Fuller as Reverend Donald Diddum Shawn Christian as Tim Bauer Lisa Kaminir as D.A. Valerie Murrow H. Richard Greene as Judge Harry Hingham Jeremy Davidson as Peter Barrett David A. Kimball as George Knott J. Patrick McCormack as Judge Sean O'Byrne Clifton Murray as Fishing Guide