Guest Stars Constance Zimmer as Claire Simms Meredith Eaton as Bethany Horowitz Lake Bell as Sally Heep Jill Brennan as Gracie Jane Anthony Heald as Judge Harvey Cooper David Dean Bottrell as Lincoln Meyer Armin Shimerman as Judge Brian Hooper Katey Sagal as Barbara Little Curtis Armstrong as Dr. Zachary Simon Ashton Holmes as Scott Little Tyler Labine as Assistant D.A. Jonathan Winant Jane Lynch as Joanna Monroe Vic Polizos as Detective Frank Richmond Ethan Phillips as Michael Schiller