Guest Stars Albert Hall as Judge Seymore Walsh Gina Philips as Sandy Hingle Jim O'Heir as Steve Mallory Vicki Lawrence as Dana Lenny Wolpe as James Russell John Short as Larry Co Starring Renée Elise Goldsberry as Singer Vatrena King as Singer Amy Castle as Young Ally Cynthia Calhoun as Singer Nicholas Pappone as Young Billy Ron Taylor as Singer in Bar Christopher Michael as Police Officer Tonya Reneé Banks as Elf Jon Simanton as Elf Cindy Sorenson as Elf Paulo Andres as Paramedic Kevin Thompson as Elf Joe Gieb as Elf Arturo Gil as Elf Valeri Ross as Security Officer