Guest Stars Roy Brocksmith as Judge Raymond Norway Curtis Armstrong as Tiny Tim Fallow Co Starring Renée Elise Goldsberry as Singer Vatrena King as Singer Sy Smith as Singer Amy Castle as Young Ally Nicholas Pappone as Young Billy Shane Dawson as Young Fish Jim Davidson as Process Server Uncredited Bonnie-Jill Laflin as Billy's Dream Girl Kristen Kerr as Robert Palmer Girl Scout Taylor-Compton as Young Georgia Hannah Kornberg as Young Elaine Samantha McElroy as Young Nell