Guest Stars Meg DeLacy as Nyla Emma Fassler as Laurel Paula Jai Parker as Margarita Jean-Baptiste Haley Lu Richardson as Ellie Dennis Roberto Urbina as Asa Rebecca Metz as Donna Marie Jordan Calloway as Margarita's Son Jenny O'Hara as Grandma Jane Erika Alexander as Mrs. Collins Max Gail as Mort Marianne Muellerleile as Mrs. Summers Brennan Keel Cook as Gael Laura Leigh Hughes as Maureen Hugh Holub as Priest Jack Betts as Grandpa Joe Ashby Mark Drexler as Bernie David Haley as Orderly Briana Roy as 9-Year-Old Trish Lawrence Stachowiak as Sebastiano Conrad