Guest Stars Bryan Batt as Mayor Quinn Maddox Anthony Ruivivar as Sheriff Michael Acosta Sean Grandillo as Eli Hudson Austin Highsmith Garces as Karen Lang Tom Everett Scott as Kevin Duval Karina Logue as Tina Hudson Co Starring Mike Vaughn voices The Voice Alec Rayme as Killer Chase McCleery Bouchie as Eddie Krueger Mary Katherine Duhon as Haley Meyers Ariadne Joseph as tbd Erica Michelle as Barista