Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Sami Gayle as Nicole "Nicky" Reagan-Boyle Amy Carlson as Linda Reagan Tony Terraciano as Jack Reagan Nicholas Turturro as Sgt. Anthony Renzulli Dylan Moore as Sydney Davenport Robert John Burke as Jyle Hogan Peter Gerety as Bishop Donovan Alice Kremelberg as Alyson Duvitz Ella Rae Peck as Caitlin Shannon Thornton as Sara David Aaron Baker as Father Leo Kristen Bush as Carol Hoffman Karen Culp as Mrs. Foster Mark Lotito as Mr. Foster Alex Charak as Wayne Foster Ariel Bonilla as Oscar Bruce Winant as Scott Rosen Dina Pearlman as Marla Kanelos Sean Cullen as Tom Breyer Jason Dyer as Mekhi Timothy Smallwood as David Carvell Leland Alexander Wheeler as Billy Yoriko Haraguchi as Rachel Co Starring Frank Fortunato as Uniformed Officer