Guest Stars Alan Dale as Caleb Nichol Navi Rawat as Theresa Diaz Amanda Righetti as Hailey Nichol Kristen Renton as Jenn Kevin Rankin as Lucas Co Starring Natalie Blalock as Gail Van Deepen Gwendoline Yeo as Amy David Rountree as Trucker Hat Guy Jerry Schumacher as Robert Campbell Christopher Showerman as Impossibly Hot Fireman