Guest Stars Carrie Preston as Elsbeth Tascioni Renée Elise Goldsberry as Geneva Pine Maura Tierney as Maddie Hayward T.R. Knight as Jordan Karahalios Vincent Curatola as Judge Tommy Politi Ato Essandoh as Elliott John Hans Tester as Judge Henrich Elizabeth Alderfer as Anna Max Gordon Moore as Dr. Rappe Derek Wilson as Morgan Michel Gill as Frederick Angela Lewis as Chenise Ronald Guttman as Judge Villapique Vincenzo Amato as Judge Ciccone Dominik Tiefenthaler as Dedrick