Guest Stars Tom Skerritt as James Paisley José Ramón Rosario as Harris the Sheriff Victor Garber as Judge Spencer Ashley Williams as Christina Carra Patterson as Bartender Auden Thornton as Darla Daniel Johnsen as Benjamin Oremus Josh Pais as Howard Michael McCormick as Al John Cariani as Stuart Slate Holmgren as Ryan Jen Ponton as Emily Bernardo Cubria as Abel