Guest Stars Anatol Yusef as Meyer Lansky Rory McTigue as Teddy Schroeder Victor Verhaeghe as Ward Boss Fleming Kevin O'Rourke as Mayor Edward Bader Chris Caldovino as Tonino Sandrelli Meg Steedle as Billie Kent Patrick Kennedy as Dr. Douglas Mason Michael Cumpsty as Father Brennan Ed Heavey as Tunney Co Starring Jacqueline Pennewill as Lillian Tracy Middendorf as Babette Christiane Seidel as Sigrid Michael Zegen as Benjamin Siegel Matt Hobby as Phillip Marc D. Donovan as Sheriff Ramsey Emily Dorsch as Cornelia Predock Nick Wyman as Dr. Landau John Harrington Bland as Scotty Gulliver Mike Houston as Ralph Jenna Gavigan as Evelyn Ned Noyes as Hank Ryan Woodle as Phil Charlotte Maier as Mrs. Landau P.J. Brown as Agent Emmett L. Coughlin E.J. Carroll as Sheriff Victor Sickles James Hosey as Mickey's delivery boy Mary Grill as Woman at Herkemeyer's Joe DeVito as Masseria's man #1 John Leonard Thompson as Father Shocke Lauren Elder as Mickey's date Peter Epstein as Masseria's man #2 John Little as Bishop Norman Wade Mylius as Elmer