Guest Stars Danielle Hanratty as Lissy Gerhardt Sammi Hanratty as Jenny Gerhardt Dylan Kenin as Randall Deacon Haley Ramm as Amber Lillian Adams as Mrs. Garrigus Rebecca Tilney as Lynette Rodney Scott as Marty Ben Cain as Mitchell Peter James Smith as Landon Wendy Haines as Karen Jacob Davich as Josh Turner Bryan Comodity Hearne as Will Breanna Cherie Wittman as Caitlyn Price