Guest Stars Callie Thorne as Sheila Keefe Dean Winters as Johnny Gavin Charles Durning as Michael Gavin Michael Mulheren as Chief Perolli Jay S. Potter as Roger Mills Siobhan Fallon as Kenny's Wife Co Starring Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Olivia Crocicchia as Katy Gavin Michael Zegen as Damian Keefe Trevor Heins as Connor Gavin Ed Sullivan as Billy Warren Peggy J. Scott as Jeannie Reilly Neal Jones as Peter Jimmy Burke as Andrew Lyndon L. Byers as Ryan Donald Corren as Kevin Larry McGee as Ref Johnathan Tchaikovsky as Murphy Kid Matthew Arkin as Dr. Thompkins Joe Murphy as Vinny J. Bernard Calloway as Larry Jack Conforti as Neighbor Sharron Bower as Patty Dan Flood as FDNY Player #1 Eric Bini as NYPD Player #1