Guest Stars Callie Thorne as Sheila Keefe Robert John Burke as Father Mickey Gavin Michael Mulheren as Chief Perolli Jay S. Potter as Roger Mills Patricia Velasquez as Nez Co Starring Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Michael Zegen as Damian Keefe Ed Sullivan as Billy Warren Cailin Stollar as Keela Anthony Mangano as Bobby Muhammed Cunningham as Pajama Boy Jimmy Burke as Andrew Mackenzie Connolly as Kitten Girl Lisa Barnes as Paula Jarah Mariano as Asian Girl Susan Ashton as Lauren Jill Latiano Howerton as Geneva Johnathan Tchaikovsky as Murphy Kid Zoe Alexander as Lazara Jessica O'Donohue as Heather #1 Sanjiv Jhaveri as Clinic Doctor Lethia Nall as ER Doctor Rebecca O'Donahue as Heather #2