Guest Stars Callie Thorne as Sheila Keefe Dean Winters as Johnny Gavin Charles Durning as Michael Gavin Ed Sullivan as Billy Warren Jay S. Potter as Roger Mills Jimmy Burke as Andrew Bruce Altman as Dr. Shinsky Gerry Bamman as Doctor Co Starring Trevor Heins as Connor Gavin Anthony Mangano as Bobby Jill Latiano Howerton as Geneva Robert Clohessy as Steven Teresa Yenque as Deli Owner Bryan Batt as Photographer #1 Kevin Rennard as Photographer #2