Guest Stars Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Lenny Clarke as Uncle Teddy James McCaffrey as Jimmy Keefe Robert John Burke as Father Mickey Gavin Michael Zegen as Damian Keefe Jerry Adler as Sidney Feinberg Terry Serpico as Cousin Eddie Co Starring David Call as Connor Gavin (Adult) Kate Jennings Grant as Memory Jean Annika Boras as Alice Creighton James as Colm Carmine Cangialosi as Patrick Jon Prescott as Memory Hank Jay Klaitz as Real Hank Mary Ann Hay as Real Jean Anthony Reimer as Angelo the Super Jack O'Connell as Kevin Thomas Gordon as Tony the Doorman