Guest Stars Lynn Whitfield as Paula Van Doren Conor O'Farrell as Graham Spaulding Jared Hillman as Andy Deaver Harris Laskawy as Judge H. Adderly Blake Bashoff as Patrick McCullough Kathleen Garrett as Mrs. Deaver Jacqueline Hahn as Spaudling's Ex-Wife Co Starring Eric Scott Gould as ND Agent Glenn Taranto as Marconi Marlene Brehm as Phoebe Matt Koruba as Ray