Guest Stars J.K. Simmons as Mark Wilson David Burke as Attorney Deans Michael McGrady as Bill Hyatt Jordan Baker as Lisa Hyatt Kate McNeil as Maryann Costello John Thaddeus as Ken Hammond Helen Carey as Andrea Wilson Michael Goorjian as Richard "Ricky" Wilson Dianna Miranda as Maria Rigas Sarah Rayne as Jesse Hyatt Co Starring Kathrine Herzer as 5 Year-Old Jesse Hyatt Kevin Foster as Shelby Hyatt Blair Hickey as Reporter #1 Bill Birch as Patrolman Parson Erin Carufel as Willa Hyatt Dilva Henry as Reporter #2