Guest Stars Meghan Ory as Red Riding Hood / Ruby Keegan Connor Tracy as Blue Fairy / Mother Superior Tony Amendola as Geppetto / Marco Anastasia Griffith as Abigail / Kathryn Nolan Carolyn Hennesy as Puppet Princess / Puppet Dragon / Myrna Harry Groener as Puppet Prince / Martin Co Starring Jarod Joseph as Billy Laura Bertram as Donna Luke Camilleri as Stephen Michael Strusievici as Little Fairy Tale Boy Adam Young as Child Jiminy / Pickpocket Boy Uncredited Morgan Roff as Teenage Jiminy