Special Guest Stars Joanna Gleason as Henrietta Lightstone Guest Stars Debra Mooney as Judge P. Spindle Jeffrey Tambor as Sid Herman Tom Bower as John Pierce Deirdre O'Connell as Jenny Baldwin Nicolas Surovy as Richard Baldwin John Marzilli as Bud Reynolds Pete Siragusa as Dom Co Starring Jim Rash as Quimby James Geralden as Detective John Carringhan Uncredited Patricia Wettig as Allison Tucker Jonathan Tucker as Chad Baldwin Jonathan Tucker as James Tucker