Guest Stars Deirdre Lovejoy as Detective Linda Cutter Enrico Colantoni as Mayor Billy Conley Bethany Joy Lenz as April David Keeley as Caleb O'Connor Co Starring Sarah Power as Jennifer Windham Glenda Braganza as Darcy Campano Clive Walton as District Attorney Richard Zeppieri as FBI Agent Finnegan Suneel Joshi as Reporter Amrit Kaur as Staffer Ola Sturik as News Anchor Terry Hart as Store Manager Kimmy Choi as Teacher Uncredited Steve Whistance-Smith as Unhinged Man