Guest Stars Aunjanue Ellis as Madeleine Hightower Gregory Itzin as Virgil Minelli Pruitt Taylor Vince as J.J. LaRoche Megan Gallagher as May Nelson Angela Gots as Roxy Rhodes Marisa Echeverria as Lailah Bloom Matt Cates as Santa Tony David Alan Basche as Dr. Jack Wilder Sarah Adina as Apartment Manager Peter Xifo as Santa Bob Co Starring Biff Wiff as Benjamin Ripple Todd Jeffries as First Officer