Guest Stars Travis Fimmel as Mason Boyle Afemo Omilami as The Chief Co Starring Sydney Sweeney as Kayla Edwards Pam Dougherty as Principal Dennis Keiffer as Fugitive Monica Pena as Sobbing Woman Emma Fuhrmann as Sissy Peele Julia Self as Kate Edwards Anne Clarke as Laura Ross Austin Chittim as Cowboy Megan Bell as Little Girl Sophie Tamara Jolaine as Sophie's Mother Kasey Stevens as Waitress Sue Amanda Rivas as Cowgirl Lizzy Erinn Allison as Jesse Lynn Peele Tom Booker as Insurance Manager Libby Villari as Jan Boyle David Born as Paul Lofgrun Todd Allen as Mike Edwards