Main Characters Host Connor Ratliff The Human Fish Hallie Bulleit Shannon O'Neill Patrick Cotnoir Alex Clute Bill Florio Bethany Hall Murf Meyer Mike Yannich Jon Vafiadis Bananaman Vacation Jason
Recurring Guest Characters Will Ferrell 3 guest appearances Jason Mantzoukas 2 guest appearances Paul Scheer 2 guest appearances Abbi Jacobson 2 guest appearances Ellie Kemper 2 guest appearances Seth Meyers 1 guest appearances Hannibal Buress 1 guest appearances Talib Kweli 1 guest appearances Nicole Byer 1 guest appearances Matt Walsh 1 guest appearances Aubrey Plaza 1 guest appearances Hasan Minhaj 1 guest appearances Roger, the Leader of the Cave Maniacs 1 guest appearances Sasheer Zamata 1 guest appearances Colin Quinn 1 guest appearances Sean Combs 1 guest appearances Zach Galifianakis 1 guest appearances John Hodgman 1 guest appearances John Starks 1 guest appearances Lena Dunham 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 » ⇥