Recurring Guest Characters Cirie Fields 11 guest appearances Quentin Jiles 11 guest appearances Kate Chastain 11 guest appearances Arie Luyendyk Jr. 11 guest appearances Andie Thurmond 11 guest appearances Christian De la Torre 10 guest appearances Rachel Reilly 9 guest appearances Stephanie Lagrossa 9 guest appearances Cody Calafiore 8 guest appearances Shelbe Rodriguez 8 guest appearances Anjelica Conti 8 guest appearances Kyle Cooke 6 guest appearances Amanda Clark 6 guest appearances Ryan Lochte 5 guest appearances Michael Davidson 5 guest appearances Azra Valani 4 guest appearances Brandi Glanville 3 guest appearances Robert ‘Bam' Nieves 3 guest appearances Geraldine Moreno 3 guest appearances Carsten "Bergie" Bergersen 3 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 » ⇥