Guest Stars Callie McClincy as Holly Holter Melinda McGraw as Patricia McCready C.J. Hoff as Aaron McCready Madelyn Deutch as Dakota M.C. Gainey as Bob Gabriel Michael Bateman as Joshua Austin Claire Bronson as Evelyn Bailey Jean Louisa Kelly as Dr. Claire Larry Poindexter as Peter Bailey Thomas Blake, Jr. as Kirby Alex Shaffer as Jason Co Starring Lacy Camp as Betsy Austin Tyler Mazzei as Beacon Boy Dakota Lee as Mindy Austin Vance Griswold as Boy One Kyle Coates as Father Bernie Brown as Boy Two Ginny MacColl as Gramma Uncredited Charmin Lee as Rose Giles
