Guest Stars Aldis Hodge as Jordan/Akinbode Idara Victor as Abigail Amy Gumenick as Philomena Cheer Jamie Harris as John Robeson Robert Beitzel as Selah Strong Jonathan Coyne as Col. Jonathan Cooke Christopher Stephens as Continental Officer Prentiss Davis as Townsman/Prisoner Eamon Sylvias Hyland as Lieutenant Erica LeHuray as Townsperson Greg Cooper as Warden Lowrey Brown as Captain Blake Arthur Bridgers as Captain Henry Keith Flippen as Officer #2 Ken Arnold as Merchant Estes Tarver as Captain John Curran as Daniel Weir David Lee Nelson as Officer #1 Tavis L. Baker as Redcoat Guard Dietrich Teschner as Militiaman John Newberry as Continental Soldier James Nevins as Merchant Scott Mielock as British Officer Andrew McKeough as John Carter Thor Macht as Civilian / Continental Soldier / Tory Ramsey Hanchette as Dinner Guest