Guest Stars Scott Thompson as Jimmy Price Aaron Abrams as Brian Zeller Kacey Rohl as Abigail Hobbs Gina Torres as Phyllis "Bella" Crawford Molly Shannon as Mother Co Starring Vladimir Jon Cubrt as Garret Jacob Hobbs Krista Patton as Louise Hobbs Azeem Nathoo as Convenience Store Clerk Lindsey Connell as Marcy O'Halloran Nicholas Bode as Christopher O'Halloran Brendan Heard as Jesse Turner Austin Macdonald as C.J. Lincoln Duncan McLeod as Mr. O'Halloran Sophie Holdstock as Mrs. Turner