Guest Stars Larry Storch as Tony Santini Peter Graves as Rev. Gerald Whitney Alan Young as Phil Sharp Mitzi Hoag as Renata Santini Vivian Blaine as Barbara Sharp June Allyson as Audrey Wilder Van Johnson as Bert Wilder Roz Kelly as Reverend Whitney's girlfriend Co Starring Renata Vanni as Tony's Mother Tony La Torre as Angelo Santini Mario Bellini as Uncle Gino Jennifer Surprenant as Maria Kelly Greenwood as Teresa