Guest Stars Todd Giebenhain as Frank Marolla Kate Micucci as Shelley Collins Jenny Slate as Joan Wrightsdale Co Starring Rylie Cregut as Hope Chance Baylie Cregut as Hope Chance Trace Garcia as 3-6 Year Old Jimmy Dan Coscino as Dancin' Dan Marcus Choi as Mailman David Ury as Easter Joe Thomas Crawford as Dr. Trabert