Guest Stars Dave Allen as Jeff Rosso Ben Foster as Eli Kevin Corrigan as Toby Jason Schwartzman as Howie Gelfand Co Starring Sarah Hagan as Millie Kentner Jerry Messing as Gordon Crisp Natasha Melnick as Cindy Sanders Stephen Lea Sheppard as Harris Trinsky Trace Beaulieu as Hector Lacovara JoAnna Garcia Swisher as Vicki Appleby Kayla Ewell as Maureen Sampson Uncredited David Koechner as Waiter