Guest Stars David Eigenberg as Firefighter Christopher Herrmann Jason Beghe as Sergeant Hank Voight James Vincent Meredith as Judge Gary Basaraba as Defense Attorney William O'Boyle Waleed Zuaiter as Amir Nasiri Mouzam Makkar as Kalila Rafiq Wesam Keesh as Jafar Boustani Rom Barkhordar as Prof. Jacob Abrishami Maya Maniar as Adara Mary Beth Fisher as Trial Judge Co Starring Lindsey Pearlman as ME Joy Fletcher Tyrone Phillips as Tyrone Jones Karin Anglin as Alexa Grant Mark Collins as Juror #8 Jack Ball as Joey Sahar Bibiyan as Mitra Nasiri David Kaplinsky as Matt Damian Conrad-Davis as Byron Welch Holly Nordquist as Melanie Burke Ashika Sachdev as Chandra Paul Michael Thomson as Juror #1 Julie Beal as Juror #5 Jane Baxter Miller as Foreperson Amir Yousuf as Teen