Guest Stars Judith Light as Carolyn Rice Kathleen Chalfant as Margaret Brennan Donna Murphy as Grace Russo Auden Thornton as Gemma Ashford Jeremy Davidson as Calvin Ferretti Domenick Lombardozzi as Jerry Brennan Brown as Garrett Holland Lee Tergesen as Mike Slater Bill Irwin as Judge John Finn as Don Roderick Hill as Mr. Fiorita Adam Chanler-Berat as Lester Roslyn Ruff as Dr. Hillary Baldridge Clea Lewis as Tanya Gibson Becky Ann Baker as Eloise Kirk Ann Harada as Judge Lillian Hsu Co Starring Lauren Blumenfeld as Lucy Alexander Leslie Lyles as Gail Meyers Catherine Missal as Young Amy Mandy Gonzalez as Mother Gigi Stone Woods as Reporter #2 Lolita Foster as Bailiff Daniel Sovich as Young Billy Mario Bósquez as Reporter #1 Amanda Quaid as Jury Foreperson Shauna Miles as Danya Bob Ari as Juror Omar Sharif Scroggins as Inmate