Guest Stars Scott Michael Foster as Nathaniel Plimpton III David Hull as Josh "White Josh" Wilson Michael McMillian as Tim Esther Povitsky as Maya Amy Hill as Lourdes Chan Alberto Isaac as Joseph Chan Stephnie Weir as Karen Patton Oswalt as J. Castleman Co Starring Danny Jolles as George Johnny Ray Rodriguez as Mexican Lawyer / Accidentes Guy Jamie Kaler as Whitworth Matt Knudsen as Stonebrow