Guest Stars David Eigenberg as Firefighter Christopher Herrmann Michael Rispoli as John Beckett Sofia Milos as Defense Attorney Mary Willis Jim Ortlieb as Judge Jessie Fisher as Gail Marcus Co Starring Matthew C. Yee as Ronnie Chen Lindsey Pearlman as ME Joy Fletcher John Kelly as Captain Al Fogarty Vincent Teninty as Officer Hawkins Kiley B. Moore as Mistress Barbara Figgins as Vanessa Caufield Spenser Stokes as Officer Jeff Jonesy Jude Roche as Bartender Trevor Fahnstrom as Ted "TJ" Cody Jr. Peter Moore as Married Guy Meg Thalken as Assistant Kurt Ehrmann as Chief Joel Tiberg Reggie Baker as Judge Jerome Lewis Rebekah Ward as Jessica Cody