Guest Stars Sara Mornell as Carole Tobey Richard Crenna as Jared Duff Tom Welling as Rob Meltzer Jessica Wesson as Katie Albright Brent Sexton as Oscar Ray Pant, Jr. Granville Van Dusen as Judge Clarence Faraday Allan Rich as Jim Southam Robin Gammell as Judge Salinger Lee Garlington as Dr. Kemper Bob Stephenson as Mr. Dimeola Armin Shimerman as Anthony Cara David Burke as Father Paul Girardi Elizabeth Dennehy as Atty. Salias Ray Xifo as Prof. McWhirter Anne De Salvo as Barb Galanelle Craig Patton as Disgruntled Husband Nigel Gibbs as Judge Birk Christine Kapetan as Mrs. Dimeola