Guest Stars Laura Benanti as USPIS Agent Edie Max Casella as Joe Delicious Mamoudou Athie as Carl Mary Grill as Federal Agent Mary Phil Reeves as Gene Jeffrey Vincent Parise as Carlos Catrina Ganey as Judge Westlake Co Starring Meredith Handerhan as Stenographer Devika Bhise as Sexy Crayon Gabrielle Ryan as Sexy Dumbledore Piper Jones as Little Girl #1 Benny Elledge as Bouncer Logan Riley Bruner as Bike Thief Tarik Davis as Orderly Clifton Dunn as DJ Ashlynn Alexander as Resident Ripley Jones as Little Girl #2 Cate Smit as Dr. Weber Linden Tailor as Paramedic #2 Ben Johnson as Little Girl's Dad Ryan Speakman as Paramedic #1 Lisha McKoy as Nurse Jerah Milligan as Cop #2 Johnny Wu as Cop #1 Bianca Haase as Rachel Elaine Hyman as Old Lady Tony Scheinman as Crazy Man Kevin Elden as Dr. Edwards Ben Hollandsworth as Bartender Mike Beaver as Other Nate