Guest Stars Ben Lawson as DA Peter Garrett Tara Karsian as Tanya Kathleen Chalfant as Margaret Brennan Patrick Fischler as ADA Alan Markes Trisha LaFache as ADA Krista Reed Dean Cameron as Judge Mike McGowan Carl Lumbly as Tyson Cobb Mercedes Mason as Elena Garcia Adam Bartley as Marcus Weeks Ryan Sands as Gerald Wright Haley Strode as Susan Bauer Swati Kapila as Abigail Martin Lawrence Pressman as Ivan Sturgill Arron Shiver as Jacob Tanner Co Starring Phil Idrissi as Judge Kendall Thompson Heather Olt as Karen Walker Angelica Ross as Valentina Jen Richards as McKayla Dale Waddington Horowitz as Judge Melanie Cochran Juan Monsalvez as Bryce Goodman Drew Brooks as Philip Sherman Judith Benezra as Jury Foreman Angela Landis as Kelly Spencer Natalie Britton as Sarah Holt Ben Franczuszki as Kyle Moore Brad Gage as Chuck Miller