Special Guest Stars Joan Cusack as Sheila Jackson Bradley Whitford as Abraham Paige Guest Stars Laura Slade Wiggins as Karen Jackson Vanessa Bell Calloway as Carol Fisher Jake McDorman as Mike Pratt Bernardo de Paula as Beto Maile Flanagan as Connie Bill Brochtrup as Hal E.J. Bonilla as Jesus Dan Donohue as Alistair Huddleston Jake Dogias as Young Doctor Lisa Long as Scotty Co Starring Michael Patrick McGill as Tommy Isidora Goreshter as Svetlana Yevgenivna Kerry O'Malley as Kate Jeff Doucette as Uncle Matt Donzaleigh Abernathy as Tawny Ron Butler as Advisor Scotty Crowe as Dr. Robert Henry Monfries as Dutch Uncredited Doby Daenger as Barfly